2001 Marcus Ave., Suite N 125, Lake Success, NY 11042
Personal Injury,
Medical Malpractice,
& Toxic Tort Law Firm
We are a boutique that blends sophisticated legal expertise with a service-oriented approach to our clients’ matters

Medical Malpractice Newsletter

Informed Refusal for Patients Who Refuse to Follow Treatment Advice

Medical malpractice is largely governed by state law and case law precedent. Thus, generalizations must be checked against the applicable state law standards. One commonality, however, among most jurisdictions, is the notion that a patient may sue a health care provider if there was a lack of “informed consent.” In other words, if a patient undergoes a medical procedure and suffers from an unexpected complication, he should consider filing a civil action based on the theory that the procedure’s potential consequences were not fully explained.

Informed Refusal

On the other hand, when a patient refuses medical recommendations and, as a result, suffers injury, he may sue for negligence based on a lack of “informed refusal.” Although there are many jurisdictional distinctions in this area of the law, patients who seek to bring such an action should, at minimum, be aware of some of the basic elements of a claim based on lack of informed consent.

Patients generally have the right to refuse a physician’s medical recommendations, such as specific treatment or home-care instructions. Sometimes they exercise this right and refuse treatment out of reluctance or fear of the recommended care. Whatever the reason, if a patient refuses treatment and the practitioner fails to directly discuss the possible and probable consequences, the patient’s ability to bring a successful malpractice action is increased.

Determining Whether Informed Refusal Was Effective

Patients who wish to bring an action should determine if the informed refusal was effective. They may do this by recalling if the physician explained and documented the following:

  • The recommended treatment, procedure, test, etc.
  • The reasons for the recommendation
  • The risks that may result from refusal

The patient should have been encouraged to discuss such issues and the reasons for refusal. If a patient indicated that he did not really understand the possible consequences of the refusal, the ramifications of refusing treatment should have been further explained until the patient understood. If a physician does not take the time to address these types of concerns, a patient will have a better chance of being successful in such an action for lack of informed refusal.

It should be noted, however, that even when the elements of informed consent are satisfied (and the practitioner had been thorough and diligent) the physician is not necessarily free from liability. Although it may be a weaker argument, the patient may still assert that he would have acted differently had the practitioner more clearly explained the consequences of refusal.

  • Medical Malpractice and Respondeat Superior
    While the pleading and proof requirements for a medical malpractice action can vary significantly from state to state, most states require the injured patient to show that the practicing physician failed to act in accord with the... Read more.
  • HMO Liability in Medical Malpractice Cases
    Some state medical malpractice laws granted patients the right to sue their Health Management Organizations (HMOs) for actions which injured them. As a result of their active roles in medical care decisions, HMOs have been held liable... Read more.
  • Cardiological Malpractice
    Cardiological specialists are required to adhere to a strict standard of care in diagnosis and treatment. If a specialist deviates from the standard of care and, as a result, a cardiac patient suffers an injury, then the specialist must... Read more.
  • Birth Injuries Resulting From Medical Malpractice
    Medical malpractice usually involves negligence on the part of a health care professional. As professionals, health care providers, e.g., doctors, surgeons, and nurses, are held to a standard of care for the services they provide. This... Read more.
Medical Malpractice News Links
Share This Page: